Time for the Bears' Annual Caleb Hanie Demotion


Someone please steal Jerry Angelo and Mike Martz’s cell phones and make sure that Todd Collins’ phone number has been deleted from them.  After Saturday’s 10-3 win over the Bills, the Bears lined up for what seemed like a routine Monday-after practice.  Then Mike Martz called rookie quarterback Nathan Enderle’s name to take snaps with the second team.  Don’t look now, but it’s time for the annual Caleb Hanie demotion and we’re not even into the regular season yet.

Here’s head coach Lovie Smith (because Martz isn’t available to the media until Wednesday) on the changes to the quarterback rotation :

“After you play a game, your reps change a little bit based on what you’ve done,” Smith said. “We got Nathan Enderle a couple more reps today with the 2s. He did some good things in the game. He hadn’t really gotten a lot of reps in practice.”

During the last preseason, Hanie injured his shoulder in the first preseason game, necessitating the Bears to fulfill Mike Martz’s wish for a veteran backup.  What they got instead was Todd Collins, the most pathetic excuse for a quarterback since Jonathan Quinn, ,and that’s saying something here in Chicago.

Back in April, the Bears drafted Nathan Enderle and shortly after, Mike Martz said the Bears didn’t draft him to be the #3 quarterback.  It didn’t take him long to start pushing his agenda and start pushing Caleb Hanie out the door.   If Hanie isn’t going to be the #2 quarterback, there are 2 key things that the Bears need to do.  Check ‘em out after the jump.

  1. If Hanie isn’t going to be your primary backup to Cutler, there is no sense to keep him on the roster.  He’s just occupying space and taking reps away from Enderle, whom the Bears and Mike Martz seem intent on developing.  Let Hanie go.
  2. Go get a veteran quarterback.  No disrespect to Enderle, but a rookie quaterback in Mike Martz’s system has virtually no chance for success.  As we learned last season, the backup quarterback is tremendously important, especially behind this sorry excuse for an offensive line.  I’m not sure if Mike Martz has enough juice to drag Marc Bulger out of “retirement” or if there’s another experienced vet that knows the Martz system, but again, if Hanie isn’t part of the solution, he’s part of the problem.

I think the Bears are making a big mistake by pushing Hanie to the side.  Now maybe this is just another motivational tactic (see: Knox, Johnny), but with the limited reps, they need to focus on getting them to the right people, people who will contribute.

Hanie did solid work in the NFC Championship game relieving Todd Collins, whose ineffectiveness may have cost the Bears a trip to the Super Bowl when he relieved Jay Cutler.  What if Hanie had gotten meaningful snaps the week leading up to the NFC title game instead of Collins?

Did Hanie look great in the preseason opener against the Bills?  No.  Consider that behind that line with that blocking, Peyton Manning wouldn’t have looked good either.    If the Bears were going to do any demoting on Monday, I give you exhibits A and B, J’Marcus Webb and Lance Louis.  If anyone needs a message sent, those two should be tops on the list.

Follow me on Twitter @BearGogglesOn and follow the new official site page @Bear_Goggles.  You can keep up with us on Facebook too.

BEAR DOWN!!!

Next Bears Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Buffalo BillsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

  • flowermike

    Every day I wake up hoping to read Boomer reporting the signing of any o line help.

    Today, I read about a 225 DE who failed in Buffalo, a team that devastated our line just 3 days ago.

    Now Boom makes me aware that Caleb Hanie, a very solid kid with upside, is being replaced with a raw rookie that I had never heard of out of college. Hanie played the Champinship game with moxy and strength and I was set on him backing Jay up… I think he can develop into a #1 once Jay gets injured this season.

    But the strength of a pre season game trumps the championship game and another talent won’t be developed. This is contagious for our Bears.

    And Martz is pulling all the levers with an offense that may not see a third year.

    I’m going back to bed.

  • flowermike

    Every day I wake up hoping to read Boomer reporting the signing of any o line help.

    Today, I read about a 225 DE who failed in Buffalo, a team that devastated our line just 3 days ago.

    Now Boom makes me aware that Caleb Hanie, a very solid kid with upside, is being replaced with a raw rookie that I had never heard of out of college. Hanie played the Champinship game with moxy and strength and I was set on him backing Jay up… I think he can develop into a #1 once Jay gets injured this season.

    But the strength of a pre season game trumps the championship game and another talent won’t be developed. This is contagious for our Bears.

    And Martz is pulling all the levers with an offense that may not see a third year.

    I’m going back to bed.

  • venomlash

    I’m fine with the Bears giving Enderle more practice reps in order to build him up as a player, but their primary backup at this point has GOT TO BE Hanie. Enderle showed some skills, sure, but he also made a lot of rookie mistakes; he had trouble maneuvering to avoid pressure, and he didn’t have the best judgment when making throws. Having him and Hanie share reps while practicing? Fine and dandy. Send Enderle in as a second-stringer? Better Grossman than him, really. Maybe once he’s got a season or two of coaching and experience under his belt.

  • venomlash

    I’m fine with the Bears giving Enderle more practice reps in order to build him up as a player, but their primary backup at this point has GOT TO BE Hanie. Enderle showed some skills, sure, but he also made a lot of rookie mistakes; he had trouble maneuvering to avoid pressure, and he didn’t have the best judgment when making throws. Having him and Hanie share reps while practicing? Fine and dandy. Send Enderle in as a second-stringer? Better Grossman than him, really. Maybe once he’s got a season or two of coaching and experience under his belt.