Chicago Bears GM Phil Emery: Innocent Until Proven Angelo

There has been a lot of negativity surrounding Phil Emery’s first draft as the Chicago Bears GM.  I get it.  I’m with you, sort of.  I understand the questions about neglecting the offensive line.  I share those concerns.

Like most of you, I’ve endured the last decade of Jerry Angelo drafts and I’m afraid I’ve become a little paranoid, a little jaded.  It’s time to put the past in the past and start looking forward.  It’s time to cut Phil Emery and little slack and see if he can deliver where his predecessor failed.

Jerry Angelo came in talking about floors and ceiling like he was a master builder, but by the time he left town, most of us wouldn’t trust him to build an outhouse.  Jerry wanted to know a players’ floor, a minimum threshold the he believed a player would achieve.  Emery appears to be the anti-Jerry.

Emery echoed a common theme from his introductory press conference through this weekend’s draft wrap-up, a desire to find dynamic playmakers who can step in to most quickly help the Bears win a championship.  Phil seems to be more interested in a player’s ceiling than his floor.  That’s reflected in what many of us would consider risky picks.

That’s why he took a big risk on Alshon Jeffery, a wide receiver who has limitless potential (a high ceiling), but could be a major bust (the floor could drop out from under him).  I appreciate and respect that.

Emery took another gamble with Evan Rodriguez, a tight end/H-back tweener who could create major mismatches in the seam.  He’s another character question mark that could end up sitting next to Sam Hurd.  (OK, maybe I’m exaggerating).

We bemoan the 8th safety the Bears have drafted in as many years.  You know how many of those guys Emery drafted?  Yup, just Brandon Hardin.  Emery inherited those others.  Maybe Hardin is the next Mike Brown?  He’s got all the physical tools and measurables.  So what if he missed last season with an injury?  Maybe that’s not a real issue, but because JA had a pre-injured pre-requisite, we see the worst.

We’ve been brainwashed by the Dan Bazuins and Michael Okwos of Jerry’s world to see if the Shea McClellins and Alshon Jefferys of the world are legit.  In our justice system, you’re innocent until proven guilty.  All I’m asking of the angry mob is to give Phil the same chance, he’s innocent until proven Angelo.


Next Bears Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Buffalo BillsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

  • DustinOrndorff

    Please tell me why we need to cut anybody any amount of slack Bears fans have seen great defenses come and go with no championships to show for it so now that they are starting to look like they have a potent offense fans want to make sure Emery isn’t going to pull an Angelo and not address the underlined needs and not putting the pieces of the puzzle in place to win the BIG ONE…………We don’t want another tenure of championship caliber talent gone to waste..

  • BearGogglesOn

     @DustinOrndorff If we had championship caliber talent on this team, we’d have a championship and Jerry Angelo would still be the Bears’ GM.  The fact is, there were tons of holes on this roster, especially on the offensive side of the ball. 
    I agree that now the offense appears to be catching up and possibly passing the defense.  Maybe instead of winning games 13-10, we’ll be winning games 31-27?  As long as the W’s stack up and we get a Super Bowl, it won’t matter.
    The whole point of this post was that we don’t know enough about these players to make a judgement.  You’re playing judge, jury and executioner before anyone has taken a single snap.  We need to see these guys in action before we decide if Emery is a genius or just the next Jerry Angelo.

  • Mr.Pickles

    Completely agree with this.  Now that I’ve had a few days to think this draft over I’m a little less indifferent to it.  Obviously this is all speculation but it seems to me like they were targeting guys with some versatility and big upside.  Sure there’s a chance McClellin could get stuck between DE and LB and never find a true position, Jeffery could eat his way out of the league, and Hardin might only resemble Mike Brown in his propensity to be injured, but there’s also a fair chance all of these guys turn out to be beasts.  All these guys deserve a season or two before passing judgment on Emery.  There’s no questions the roster is a bit on the thin side these days, perhaps drafting versatility is a way of restocking and avoiding a rebuilding project.