Stale Draft Bears: Top 5 Draft Mistakes of the Last 10 Years

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse


CedBensonSuperBowlFumble_thumb_2In the midst of all the mock drafts and draft build up, I thought that we’d take a break and reminisce on the last 10 years of Bears draft picks. In the first of 2 pieces, I will break down the worst Bears picks of last 10 years in something I call Stale Draft Bears (thanks – I’ll be here all week). With being so many, it was not as easy as I thought and it was a little disturbing to say the least.

There are many factors to consider when adding a player to this list which include: the pick that was given up for the player, the player’s production for the Bears, injuries, how much of a reach was the pick and finally, the team’s need for the player’s position at the time of the pick. If you are one of those people that believe that an injury cannot give a player a “bust” label…..you’re wrong.

Phil Emery, if you’re reading this, which you are probably not, please take notes:

#5- Brandon Hardin 2012, 3rd Rd #16, S – Shea McClellin 2012, 1st Rd #19, DE/LB

Aug 18, 2012; Chicago, IL, USA; Washington Redskins tight end Logan Paulsen (82) is tackled by Chicago Bears free safety Brandon Hardin (35) during the second half at Soldier Field. Hardin was injured on the play. The Bears won 33-31. Mandatory Credit: Dennis Wierzbicki-USA TODAY Sports

I couldn’t decide what was worse here, so I included both. The inaugural draft for GM Phil Emery, aside from Alshon Jeffrey, was a forgettable one to say the least. Hardin, who was considered a reach at the time, was projected to be drafted in the 4th round by many mock drafts. Phil Emery drafted Hardin who missed the whole 2011 college season due to injury and guess what? He got injured again in 2012. He was released by the Bears without ever playing a regular season snap before the 2013 season. How do you not even make the team when your competition is Chris Conte, Craig Steltz and Major Wright? If you pick a safety in round 3, he should be starting by year #3. Not only did he go in the other direction, he couldn’t even earn a roster spot on a team with arguably the worst safety group in the NFL. I understand that he was injured, but he would have not made the team even if he was healthy.

Dec 30, 2012; Detroit, MI, USA; Chicago Bears defensive end Shea McClellin (99) during the game against the Detroit Lions at Ford Field. Mandatory Credit: Tim Fuller-USA TODAY Sports

Many probably think I’m jumping the gun on Shea. However, when the team is switching your position after 2 seasons and you are a long shot to start, this is called “getting desperate.” Coming out of college, according to many scouts, McClellin was best suited for a 3-4 defensive scheme and was noted as a speed rusher. He has not proven to have the pass rushing ability and the Bears do not run a 3-4, further raising questions about this inaugural pick for the Bears’ new GM. Having only 6.5 sacks and 44 tackles in 2 full seasons is unacceptable. I’m not sure how poor run stopping skills, poor ability to get off of a block and inconsistent pass rushing abilities translates into a successful NFL linebacker either? I hope he proves me wrong. It’s safe to say at this point that these are picks that Phil Emery would love to have back.

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Next Bears Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Buffalo BillsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Brandon Hardin Cedric Benson Chicago Bears Chris Williams Dan Bazuin Gabe Carimi Shea Mcclellin

  • Johnathan Wood

    Major Wright does not belong on this list. He was a 3rd rounder who started for 3 years. He was never a stud, but wasn’t terrible most of the time either. That’s at least a competent 3rd round pick.

    • Michael Curcio

      Yeah, at the very least I could have had Dvoracek and Marcus Harrison up there with him. I think I was harder on him because he was our first pick that year and Im still sour after last year.

  • Erik Lambert

    Jarron Gilbert or Juaquin Iglesias in 2009?

    • Michael Curcio

      Erik they are mentioned at the bottom of the piece. Gilbert was just on the fringe I just feel Hardin was a bigger wasted pick. You could probably make a case for either though

  • Mike Flannery

    I wish this would have been for the last 11 years instead of 10, so I could vent about Michael Haynes. Worst pick ever. What hurts more is that Troy Polamalu went 2 picks later. The Bears did pick up Tillman in the 2nd and Briggs in the 3rd that year, but it’s hard not to think of what could have been if the Bears would have taken Polamalu over Haynes.